Old Town’s Notable Residents


One of my favorite burial grounds/cemeteries is the Old Town Cemetery in the city of Newburgh. One of the many reasons it is a favorite destination is because of the notable people interred within its bounds. Two such notables are congressmen, Thomas McKissock and Jonathan Fisk.

McKissock was born in Montgomery, New York on April 17, 1790. The Directory of the U.S. Congress, states that he studied medicine and law. Walter Case Anthony writes that his early schooling was at the Montgomery Academy. Once admitted to the bar, he practiced in Newburgh. In 1847, he was appointed a pusine justice of the New York State Supreme Court. A pusine justice is a junior judge. Although Marcus T. Reynolds had been nominated by the governor and confirmed by the N.Y.S. Senate, he refused the position. McKissock was Governor Young’s second choice.

McKissock was elected to the 32nd Congress from March 4, 1849 to March 3, 1851. Although he ran for re-election in 1850, he was defeated for the 9th district. After his defeat, he continued to practice law. He is listed in the Newburgh Directory for 1864 as having an office at 27 Third Street in Newburgh.

Thomas McKissock passed away on June 26, 1866. According to a local paper, his funeral was held on June 30 ,and he was buried in the Old Town Cemetery. He was buried not to far from Congressman Jonathan Fisk.

Jonathan Fisk was not born in Orange County, but in New England. He was born in Amherst, New Hampshire on September 26, 1778, where he started out his professional career as a teacher. Walter Case Anthony, wrote that he was certified to teach grammar, writing, and math. He would not do this for long.

McKissock Grave-Find A Grave

In 1795 he moved to Ware, New Hampshire to further his studies and continue his teaching. This time he studied Latin and Greek. Once again, according to Anthony, he moved, this time to New York City. Fisk studied in the law office of Peter Hawes. He continued to earn money teaching. In 1799, he was allowed to practice law before the Court of Common Pleas in Westchester County. As his abilities were realized he was allowed to practice law before the state supreme court as well as the court of common pleas in both Orange as well as Ulster Counties. This was in 1800, when he also relocated to Newburgh.

Jonathan Fisk was elected to 11th Congress in 1808, for the 3rd district. He would be elected again in 1814, where he would represent the 6th district. Eventually he gave up his seat in Congress to become a S.S. Attorney.

Fisk briefly left Newburgh for New York City in 1815 when he was appointed by President James Madison a U.S. District Attorney for the Southern District of New York. Eventually Fisk returned to Newburgh in 1820, and continued to practice law. Anthony wrote in his book about prominent lawyers in Orange County published in 1917, that Fisk was investigated for charging large fees while he was a district attorney. It was believed that it hurt his business, even though he was cleared of wrong doing. He died in Newburgh on July 13, 1832.

Fisk and McKissock are two of many distinguished citizens of Newburgh buried in the Old Town Cemetery. There are prominent military men, merchants, and Captain Henry “Bully” Robinson’s mausoleum. The Cemetery is located between Grand and Liberty at South Street, next to the Calvary Presbyterian Church.

This entry was posted in Cemeteries, City of Newburgh, Education, Landmarks, Orange County and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Rules. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or fill out this form.
  • Blog Author

    AJ Schenkman

    A.J. Schenkman is the author of numerous books and articles. He is Consulting Historian for Historic Huguenot Street and Town of Gardiner Historian. Read Full

    Elizabeth Werlau

    Elizabeth Werlau is an English teacher in the Hudson Valley and is the historian for the Town of Plattekill in Ulster County. She has authored and contributed to several books on regional history, including her most recent publication, Murder and ... Read Full

    Debra Conway

    A former Features writer/Columnist for the Times Herald-Record and Director of Fort Delaware Museum of Colonial History in Narrowsburg, Debra Conway is currently the Executive Director of The Delaware Company, a nonprofit organization dedicated to ... Read Full

    Matthew Colon

    Matthew Colon enjoyed nearly a decade in public history working and volunteering for organizations including Washington’s Headquarters State Historic Site and the Historical Society of Newburgh Bay and the Highlands. Read Full

    Shannon Butler

    Shannon Butler is a Park Ranger of Interpretation and Education at Roosevelt-Vanderbilt National Historic Site in Hyde Park New York. She has also interpreted the Senate House State Historic Site in Kingston New York. Read Full
  • Categories

  • Archives